The prototype of all Florida scams

The prototype of all Florida scams

Source and license: Clason Map Co. / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain, resized

Welcome to a fool's paradise, where a Florida mirage known as Poinciana - the prototype of all Florida scams - haunts the heartland, ensnared in the clutches of the tangled mangroves and shrouded in mystery.

Poinciana was a planned community that was to be located along the Lostmans River in Monroe County, Florida. Marketed as a future "Miami of the Gulf Coast", the city was to have been built on 3 land sections totaling over 100 square miles. This specter of a settlement boasted claims of having banana, orange, lime, and coconut plants leftover from a Spanish settlement. It was nestled by the Lostmans River, deep within Monroe County, Florida.

Constructed by the Tropical Florida Development Company, this phantasmal creation was a dance with investors' cash, as they peddled almost 9,000 or 10,000 lots within the labyrinth of mangrove forests, some over a mile from the river itself. The hurricane of 1926 destroyed all structures at Poinciana, and the project was subsequently abandoned. The company's deceptive tactics continued into 1929, when company official E. S. Rood was arrested and held for a $1,000 bond on 5 charges of mail fraud from deceptive promotional fliers.

And as for the origin of the name Onion Key, local Totch Brown claimed it was from Gregorio Lopez eating his last onion there, while Charlton Tabeau claimed it was from an unidentified man who homesteaded the island with his wife and grew onions. Like a cruel joke, the history of Poinciana lingers within the Everglades, where over 2,000 lots were still privately owned as late as 1960.

Sources: Wikipedia, OpenStreetMap, Wikidata, Wikimedia Commons

Guide me

Hear this story where it happened, along with the others around it. Say how many days you have and what you are into, and we put together a route through these places, with a voice guide telling each story as you arrive.

Guide me

Written by Leroy

Discuss this with the author and others

No comments yet. Be the first to start the conversation.